An employee misses three promised callbacks. The crew finds out only after customers call the owner. A timely conversation gives everyone a fairer chance to fix the pattern.
Write down what happened
Use dates, a specific example, and the impact. Leave character judgments out of your opening. “Two customers had to call us again this week” is more useful than “You don’t care about follow-through.”
Explain the stake and ask what you missed
Tell them why the commitment matters. Then make room for their account. You may learn that the owner’s instructions conflict with the dispatch board. Own your part if the system contributed to the problem.
Agree on the next behavior
Name a repeatable action and the support needed to carry it out. For the callback example, agree on when updates will be sent, where completion is recorded, and how they can flag a problem before the deadline.
Make the follow-through fair
Set a review date and describe what you will look at. Acknowledge improvement when it happens. If the pattern persists, use your normal HR process and appropriate professional guidance.
Try it this week
Before you meet, write one observation, one question, and one proposed next action.